I should have left you right after we first had sex
Should have scrubbed your number from my hand and washed it down the drain
Because it's over. Now it's over
We should have help up until we both passed out
Should have drank to our goodbyes
Drawn the Xs on our eyes
Because it's over. Because it's over now
It's over and over
You're cashed just the same
It's hurting. It's working
It's choking the pain
I want a new life to begin
I want to start over
I want a new life
I should have saved a picture of every girl I ever met
Kissed it all goodbye and left behind some sort of proof that I exist
My television's getting blurry and I'm running out of breath
Because it's over now
Sooner or later you're cashed just the same
This hurting is working
It's choking the pain
I want a new life to begin
I want to start over
I wish I started yesterday
No more wasting
Wondering what might have been
I want to start over
I want a new life
From the first time I met you to the last time I left you
I made so many mistakes